Notable for her role as Katharine Plumber in the Broadway production of Newsies, Lindsay also starred as Glinda in the second national tour of the musical Wicked.
She earned a Bachelor of Fine Arts degree in acting and musical theatre from Carnegie Mellon University.
Her Newsies run lasted from early 2012 until late 2014.
She spent her childhood years in Rochester, New York. She married fellow musical theater performer Kevin Massey.
She and Melissa Gilbert performed together in a 2009 Paper Mill Playhouse production of Little House on the Prairie: The Musical.