She was engaged to Carson Daly before splitting in June 2001. She was engaged to Michael Axtmann but the couple later split. She then dated Zachary Kehayov and later was in a relationship with musician Erez Eisen. She and Nathan Montpetit-Howar began dating in 2019. She has been romantically linked to Ted Dhanik.
She played the love interest of Thomas Ian Nicholas' character Kevin in the American Pie films.